Rental income Budget tax changes: positive step, but missed opportunity
Forthcoming tax increases are a positive step to address tax advantages of being a landlord – but the Government could and should have gone further.
In last month’s Budget, the Chancellor announced that tax rates on income earned from renting out property would be increased by 2 percentage points from the next financial year. This is in addition to the 2 percentage-point increase on tax rates for rental income announced in the 2025 budget, also scheduled to kick in from next year. Together, these measures mean that the tax rates landlords will pay on their rental income will increase by 4 percentage points from April; basic rate-paying landlords will be taxed at 24%, higher rate payers at 44% and additional rate payers at 49%.
The Budget announcement has been criticised as a 'tax raid' on landlords by bodies like the National Residential Landlords Association. Pronouncements that the move is the final nail in the coffin for landlords have abounded, with much commentary warning that the tax rises will simply be passed onto tenants by landlords as a way of protecting their dwindling margins.
Though the new headline tax rates might make it look like landlords have been hit unreasonably hard, in fact the Autumn Budget changes only reduce somewhat the generous tax subsidy landlords — along with others making money from investments — have enjoyed. In a fiscal environment made particularly tricky by strong headwinds from geopolitical events, it’s the right move for the Government to expect this group to contribute more in tax. But the changes in the Autumn Budget, though welcome, are only piecemeal reform. The Government could have gone further with more holistic reforms to the tax regime for landlords, making the tax system fairer, less distortive and better able to support the housing outcomes the country desperately needs.
Changes rightly reduce the tax subsidy landlords have benefitted from
A simple comparison of headline income tax rates for landlords compared to employees obscures the fact that earnings from employment also have National Insurance Contributions (NICs) — both employee and employer NICS — levied on their earnings. Employee NICS are paid directly out of an employees’ earnings. Employer NICs are technically paid by employers — though it is widely accepted that this tax burden is passed onto employees in the form of lower earnings. This means employees have a significantly higher effective tax rate than those earning income from investment, who pay no NICs.
When we factor in NICs, it becomes clear that even when higher headline rates kick in next year, landlords will still enjoy significant tax advantages over those earning income from employment.
Viewed this way, the changes in the budget represent a reduction in the generosity of the tax advantage landlords have historically enjoyed (alongside others who earn income from investments rather than work). It’s right that the Government has recognised the unfairness of this tax advantage, and the combined tax changes from this year’s and last year’s Budget represent important steps to rectify it. Importantly, though, they don’t close the gap fully. As of April next year, an employee on a salary of £40,000 will pay an average effective rate of 30% tax on their income. By contrast, a landlord earning the same income from renting out a property will only pay 17% of that income in tax.
What would a more comprehensive set of reforms have looked like?
In failing to equalise the effective tax rates of landlords with those of employees, the changes announced in the budget — though a welcome step in the right direction — fall short of establishing fairness and parity in the tax treatment of income from different sources. A significant tax subsidy for landlords will stay intact.
To move towards a fairer, more efficient tax system for rental income, the Government also needs to look at the relief provided to mortgage interest costs. Prior to 2016, mortgaged landlords could deduct their full interest costs from their income tax liability. The 2016 changes reduced the generosity of this tax relief, capping it at a flat 20% relief for mortgage interest — increasing to 24% from April 2027.
This means that landlords are taxed based partially on the revenue they earn, rather than the net profit.1 Figure 2 shows how the marginal and average tax curves for a landlord with a mortgage end up notably higher as a result. The recent rise in interest rates has accentuated the impact of this discrepancy, as the average share of gross rental income spent on mortgage interest has risen from 28% in 2022, to 37% in 2023.2
This is an important issue that affects a minority of landlords — in 2024, 11% of individual landlords are mortgaged landlords, with a rental profit that exceeds £25,000 a year.
The result is a tax system that taxes landlords making large returns relatively lightly, and those with high mortgage interest costs relatively heavily, while creating an incentive for landlords to incorporate, (as this enables landlords to regain the ability to deduct full interest costs and face corporation rather than income tax rates).
This is clearly not an optimal system. As JRF has argued elsewhere, the Government could more comprehensively reform the tax regime for landlords by allowing full tax deduction of mortgage interest costs,3 and equalising tax rates for rental income, with the effective tax rates on employment income. These reforms together would ensure, more effectively than measures announced at this and last year’s Budgets, that:
- no landlord is pushed into a loss by the tax system
- income from rental property and income from work are taxed fairly and equally
- greater overall revenue is raised for the Government.
Higher headline tax rates on rental income, in conjunction with current higher interest rates and sluggish house price growth, should ensure that the welcome dampening effect of the 2016 removal of mortgage interest relief on speculative investor demand for property remains in place.
The benefits of more comprehensive tax reform
A more comprehensive package of reforms to the way landlords are taxed would increase the fairness and neutrality of the tax system, raise revenue for the Government, and ensure that the tax system doesn’t tip any landlords into unprofitability. These are all worthy objectives in their own right; but crucially, they would also support the Government in delivering more affordable housing for renters.
The increased tax receipts from equalising tax rates on rental income would provide the Government with a revenue source for uprating Local Housing Allowance (LHA) rates. Frozen LHA is driving significant economic insecurity and hardship for low-income renters, and the decision at the budget to keep the freeze in place for another year will only make this situation worse. Raising more tax revenue from landlords making very large profits, as our proposed reforms would do, would give the government a sustainable way to fund re-linking LHA every year to the keep them in line with the 30th percentile of local rents.
Our proposed tax reforms would also reduce volatility in the way the tax system impacts landlord viability across private rented sector. This is particularly important given that interest rates remain elevated and are expected to rise over the next year at least. A more predictable tax regime for landlords — and one which, rightly, places a heavier tax burden on those making the largest profits — would make it more feasible for the government to introduce caps on rent increases, something renters are sorely in need of. Making an informed policy decision about what levels of rent cap the sector could absorb without undue disruption is an easier task when the tax regime is acting to both limit the number of landlords making a loss and fairly tax the profits of those making the most money.
The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) highlighted the risk that landlords will pass the tax increases onto tenants in the form of higher rents (with landlord groups in Scotland using this as justification to lobby the Scottish government not to pass on the tax rises). Introducing rent caps alongside tax reforms would ensure that the Government’s intention to ask landlords to pay a fairer share of their income in tax would not inadvertently result in higher costs being passed down to renters already feeling the squeeze.
For the sake of tax fairness and rationality, a more durable tax regime for the private rented sector and increased tax revenue to fund much-need living standards improvements, the government mustn’t miss the opportunity at the next budget to implement a more comprehensive package of reforms to the tax regime for landlords.
Notes
1. This is only partially true because landlords can still deduct operating/maintenance costs from rental income before tax liability its calculated.
2. 37% of gross rental income equates to around 50% of income once operating/maintenance costs are accounted for.
3. As noted by Centax and others, the tax allowance for mortgage interest could either be provided through the income tax schedule or an investment allowance in the Capital Gains Tax system. There is a risk that addressing only the mortgage interest relief and not accounting for the real or opportunity cost of other investment creates a relative bias towards a debt-financed housing market. On the other hand, there is value in providing interest relief at the time landlords are paying mortgage and tax costs, rather than on the realisation of capital gains.
This comment is part of the housing topic.
Find out more about our work in this area.