Investment in place-based imagination in York and the North East
Insight into JRF's investment in imagination work in the North East — how and why we're working in a place-based way, learning and sharing as we go.
The exercise of imagination is dangerous to those who profit from the way things are because it has the power to show that the way things are is not permanent, not universal, not necessary.
Ursula Le Guin
Following Victoria’s last piece, which lays out a historic, social, economic and personal rationale explaining the work that Emerging Futures has been scaffolding2 in the region, we look at why we have been investing in place-based imagination infrastructures this year.
You might have seen our 5-day multi-city Imagination Tour with Rob Hopkins took place in July. Our first cross-regional, collaborative piece of work which brought together artists, producers and practitioners from the region to build lasting imagination infrastructures. An attempt at deep, place-based collaboration, to bolster and grow the region's collective capacity for imagining alternative futures.
Our small team is situated across York and the North East and are in regular contact with the people and communities who are prototyping alternative social, economic and climate futures. We have been delighted to have followed a trail of new projects scattered across the region, from the Weekend of Dreaming in Middlesbrough, produced by Shahda Khan and Aaron Bowman, and York’s Poesis — a community living room which nurtures radical dialogues for all ages led by Fay Andrew-Hodgkins.
The investment in this work recognises that there has already been personal, grassroots, community, creative and historic grounding in imagination work across York and the North East. A big part of the role we play is in noticing, connecting, weaving and resourcing transitions3 to take place. We are grateful to travel alongside the builders and visionaries who have been seeding and nurturing this work.
You can read this piece written by Rob Hopkins and Frances Arnold that gives a deeper dive into what happened during the Imagination Tour, whilst this serves as more of a framing piece as to why and under what context it was commissioned.
What is imagination infrastructure?
The many practitioners who collaborated on the Imagination Infrastructuring website answer this in their own words in JRF's Interrogating imagination infrastructure report:
"[Imagination Infrastructure] recognises that collective imagination is a practice that you develop over time, and therefore our capacity to do so can be strengthened. Just like with narrative work, advocacy or campaigning, or policy, collective imagination is a craft and a practice in its own right. It is ‘not a dream or ideology’. It isn’t deliberative democracy, nor is it another word for citizen assemblies. It is ‘a practice that starts by reframing the world around us in radically new ways’."
This collection of insights strengthen our investment in our hyperlocal and regional ecosystems, where we understand that further resourcing and embedding of imagination work in York and the North East can and will be ‘a divestment in the status quo, to unsettle the present and open up pathways of possibility’ to a future where people and planet can thrive.
The Collective Imagination Practice Community has wonderfully captured 10 reasons why Collective Imagination is important, which I highly recommend reading.
Imagination as luxury? A false binary
At one point in this work, we found ourselves falling into a false binary of believing that imagination practice was reserved for people with greater privilege, held out of reach from communities where everyday certainties like food, money and safety aren’t accessible. We have seen how in reality, imagination as a practice and infrastructure for world building4 is a vital tool for moving through moments of collapse, especially for communities fighting the sharpest ends of extraction, capitalism and colonialism.
One of my entry points to imagination work has been through the black feminist, afro-futurist5 works of Octavia Butler's Thrutopian6 science-fiction stories, where I recognised that imagination is far from luxurious play, but is an essential tool for survival, the medium in which a surrender to longing is so great — it might just save your life. This quote from Tricia Hersey of The Nap Ministry has always stayed with me:
"When I think about Harriet Tubman and her work on the Underground Railroad, and how her imagination led her to be able to be like, ‘I don't even know how to read. I don’t even know where I'm going. I don't have a map, but I just know that it’s freedom or death. I just know that I'm just going to walk this way and I just got a hold on until there’s something else better’."
We realised that in the North East communities have been holding down their foundations with deeply rooted imagination practice, that working-class communities have been here before and they have navigated great upheaval and transition before, and they can do it again. It’s now customary to quote the Redhills miners’ motto at each talk and in every blog, ‘The past we inherit, the future we build’. A reminder of all of the audacious visions and prototypes which live on in the communities, ancestrally and through the spirit of these places.
A mandate: how this work was commissioned
It feels important to open a window into how we’ve been working behind the scenes, naming that we are experimenting and learning whilst doing. Following a conversation where Fay from Poesis mentioned her hopes of inviting Rob Hopkins to York for one of her dialogues, Victoria Hughes had spotted the potential for bringing together other Imagination practitioners in the sector to host a series of events with Rob. From here the idea grew, and a team of hugely talented producers, artists and changemakers was assembled:
- Katie Frost, Project Manager from York
- Frances Arnold, Artist and Creative Producer from Northumberland
- Carl Joycle, Coalfield Studios in Durham
- Steven Walker, OGRE Studios in Gateshead
- Matt Golding, Antidote-National
This core team was commissioned as the tour team. Fran’s remit as Tour Producer enabled 5 incredible places to organise and host their own stop of the tour:
- Repower Collective, led by Shahda Khan in Middlesbrough
- No More Nowt, led by Aarron Bowman and Jess Hunt in Durham
- Poesis, led by Fay Andrew-Hodgkins and Sophia Cheng in York
- BloomInArt, led by Emma Wheetman and Rachel Laycock with Adam Cooper of Threads in the Ground in Hartlepool
- Building Cultures, led by Carlo Viglianisi and Dan Russell, with local collaborators in Ouseburn, Newcastle
Finding a way to hold a container that allowed for co-production from early on, as well as the resource and scaffolding to enable the imagination tour was a new challenge. We found it difficult to ‘commission’ a project that emerged through collaboration and was sparked by people on the ground, while also following due process to move funding and working in an emergent, flexible way, while trying to build space for imagination to weave through each phase of the project.
Whilst the process was imperfect, and learnings about how we might work differently next time have been emerging, we are proud of the way we were able to devolve power, trust, and decision making to the region. Each step of the process was shaped with our place-based leads, meaning we were able to co-create parameters for seed funding to be distributed in each place to cement each place's ‘what ifs’ into tangible ‘what next’s. We are still capturing and learning how power dynamics, transparency and resource come into play whilst collaborating in deeply place-based ways, and are grateful for all the feedback that will inform our continued work in place.
Starting with a ‘what if’ and seed funding for ‘what next?’
Our brief to each place recognised the ongoing work already happening, holding an intention for Rob’s training to work alongside other imaginative interventions, invitations and events: “Crucially, this is not a moment that ends when Rob leaves, but a process designed to catalyse and nurture the conditions for imagination to take root, so that communities are supported to catch the momentum, deepen relationships, and continue rehearsing their visions of a more hopefully future into reality, with care, continuity and shared ownership”.
Rob’s early requests as a collaborator on this project were to work alongside local artists, who could bring the imagination work to life, and to suggest that, where possible, we offer seed funding for prototyping after the workshops, to tease out areas for action — moving from ‘what if’ to ‘what next’. This seed funding was enabled with Liv Jackson, our Programme and Partnerships Lead, and shaped with feedback from our Place Leads. Each place was given £5,000 to distribute to the event attendees to actualise an idea, or prototype an imaginative action in their place. Each place on the tour went about this in different ways, flexibly meeting the needs of the communities they serve.
We are currently in a process of capturing the collective learning and insights from this piece of cross-regional work. We will soon be publishing the seed-funded prototypes, our own thoughts, and learnings from our Place Leads, in a digital zine.
Who are we learning from?
Sepideh Noohi, who stewarded JRF’s earlier imagination work previously wrote ‘We believe collective imagination is a capacity needed for helping us to sense, feel, imagine and build other worlds. It offers alternatives that turn us away from the extractive and broken systems that are making it impossible for people, the more-than-human world, and the planet, to thrive. We are continuing to invest in collective imagination practice because we deeply believe that if we are to build alternative futures, then we can only do so if we begin this work in very different soils’.
She was a collaborator of the Collective Imagination Practice Community — a self- governing collective now hosted by Huddlecraft and Canopi, and a virtual home to over 400 practitioners from around the world, a seed library of tools, and a vital community of practice for nurturing the skills and ecosystem around imagination.
We are delighted to have been working in close partnership with Rob Hopkins, the co-founder of Transition Network and of Transition Town Totnes, and author of several books including The Transition Handbook and most recently, How to Fall in Love with the Future: a time traveller’s guide to changing the world. His work has catalysed deep change work on self, group and system scales for over 2 decades, his podcast From What If to What Next, is often a starting point we reference for new team members. His fervent optimism is contagious, and a beautifully accessible introduction to imagining and actualising hopeful futures.
Amahra Spence, leader of Hood Futures Studio has instilled the work of rehearsal in those who have followed her work. A way of being that is so loudly ancestral, that frames archive as futurism, Amahra has paved a route centering the Black imagination, laying brick by brick on her home turf in Birmingham — she has shown us time and time again how imagination is a foundational equation in the art of world building. She shows us that imagination practice has application in all practical aspects of this work, even through Accounting in the Black Imagination.
Thank you to all who have come before us in this lineage of deeply important work, and for those we have found on the journey as teachers and fellow travellers, we are grateful for your collaboration, wise council and stewardship of this very necessary work. If you are someone in York or the North East of England who is doing this kind of work, and you’d like to get in touch, feel free to reach out to me at kate.mclaven@jrf.org.uk.
My parting words are with thanks to a new teacher Rayya (@thebreathactivist) who teaches in Where do we Begin — an incubator for Arabs longing for sovereignty and liberation. Rayya teaches from the context of SWANA (Southwest Aisa and North Africa) liberation and somatics in social justice, and facilitates land-based imagination practices.
He who has no land
Has no sea
But he who has an imagination;
Has a homelandMohmoud Darwish
Notes
These are imperfect definitions offered by the author of this blog.
- Imagination infrastructures: investment in sites of practice such as relational, material, social, civic, and natural world infrastructures, as well as laying the ground for ongoing practice through tools, programmes and projects, creating a web of support for the collective imagination practices.
- Scaffolding: the temporary or foundational support put in place to enable communities, projects, or individuals to build and sustain their work. This position is about offering support, not playing the role of the architect and builders — maintaining key decisions and work should be held by the community.
- Transitions: the work of seeding, nurturing and building new systems that move from extractive ones (for example, a capitalist economy) to regenerative ones (for example, a donut/circular economy).
- World building: the act of imagining, curating, designing and actualising a ‘new world’ through new infrastructures, architectures and ways of being in a way that offers texture, space and imagery to an idea of how our world could operate. Think Minecraft and Glastonbury.
- Afro-futurist: “A sub-category of science fiction that is concerned with visions of the future, is interested in technology, leaves the earth, skews optimistic, is centered on and predominantly written by people of African descent (black people) and it is rooted first and foremost in Africa... and does not privilege or center the West.” – Nnedi Okorafor.
- Thrutopian: a genre of climate fiction that offers a plausible, grounded route map from current predatory capitalism to a thriving society, coined by Rupert Read.
Suggested further reading
- Tricia Hersey on Rest as Resistance /185 — For The Wild
- Imagination Infrastructure — Olivia Oldham
- Change happens when our collective imagination changes — Cassie Robinson
- Visioning without execution is just expensive dreaming — Meggan Collins
- Slow Digest: Africanfuturism — Center for 21st Century Studies
This story is part of the imagination infrastructures topic.
Find out more about our work in this area.